Fresh pickleball picks, zero fluff. We may earn a small commission from links, at no cost to you. Learn more

Selkirk SLK Evo vs Franklin Ben Johns: Best Budget Pickleball Paddle?

The two most popular budget paddles, compared so you know whether the step up to the SLK Evo is worth it.

Heads up: some links on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through them I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read my disclosure.
Selkirk SLK Evo vs Franklin Ben Johns: Best Budget Pickleball Paddle?
The quick verdict

If pickleball is already your thing, spend a little more on the SLK Evo. If you're just trying it out or buying for the family, the Franklin is all you need.

Best Step-UpSelkirk SLK Evo
Check price on Amazon →
4.4 Excellent

Quick picks

Short on time? Here are my favorites at a glance.

  1. Best Step-UpSelkirk SLK Evo 4.4Beginners and casual players ready for a real paddle
    Check price
  2. Best for Trying It OutFranklin Sports Ben Johns Signature Paddle 4.2First-timers and families trying the sport
    Check price

Side-by-side comparison

Selkirk SLK EvoFranklin Sports Ben Johns Signature Paddle
AwardBest Step-UpBest for Trying It Out
Rating4.4 4.2
Best forBeginners and casual players ready for a real paddleFirst-timers and families trying the sport
Price$$$
Power7.57.0
Control8.57.5
Spin7.56.5
Comfort8.58.0
Value9.09.5
Check priceCheck price

Scores are out of 10. The highlighted cell is the best in each row.

Not sure which paddle is for you?Answer 5 quick questions and get your perfect match.
Take the quiz
Selkirk SLK Evo #1
4.4 out of 5
Best Step-Up

Selkirk SLK Evo

Best for: Beginners and casual players ready for a real paddle · $$

A huge step up from wood or bargain-bin paddles without the premium price. It's forgiving and comfortable, and it comes from a brand with a strong reputation.

Power7.5
Control8.5
Spin7.5
Comfort8.5
Value9.0

What I love

  • Forgiving and easy to control
  • Great value from a top brand
  • Comfortable grip

Keep in mind

  • Less spin than raw carbon paddles
  • You may outgrow it as you improve
Check price on Amazon →
Franklin Sports Ben Johns Signature Paddle #2
4.2 out of 5
Best for Trying It Out

Franklin Sports Ben Johns Signature Paddle

Best for: First-timers and families trying the sport · $

If you're not sure pickleball will stick yet, start here. It's affordable, durable and easy to find, and it plays well enough to learn proper strokes.

Power7.0
Control7.5
Spin6.5
Comfort8.0
Value9.5

What I love

  • Very affordable
  • Durable
  • Easy to find in stores and online

Keep in mind

  • Basic feel and spin
  • Most players upgrade within a year
Check price on Amazon →

Your first paddle doesn’t need to cost a fortune. These two are the ones I recommend most to new players, and the right choice really comes down to how hooked you are.

The big difference

  • Selkirk SLK Evo: a “real” paddle at a fair price. It’s more forgiving, quieter and more comfortable, and it’ll carry you well past the beginner stage.
  • Franklin Ben Johns Signature: cheap, tough and easy to find. Perfect for learning strokes, but most players want to upgrade within a year.

Side by side

Selkirk SLK Evo Franklin Ben Johns
Personality Forgiving step-up Simple starter
Best for Weekly players First-timers & families
Spin Moderate Basic
Price $$ $

Who should NOT buy each one

Even great paddles aren’t right for everyone. Think about your level, your arm and how you like to win points. If you’re unsure, a forgiving all-court paddle is always the safer choice.

Care tips for both paddles

  1. Keep your paddle out of hot cars. Heat can damage the core.
  2. Use a paddle cover to protect the face and edge guard.
  3. Clean the face with a damp cloth to keep the grit working.
  4. Replace the overgrip when it gets slippery.

FAQ

Are both paddles USA Pickleball approved?

Yes, both are approved for sanctioned play, but always double-check the current approved list before a tournament.

Can I try before I buy?

Many clubs and pro shops have demo programs. If you can, hit with a paddle for 15 minutes before buying. It tells you more than any review.

Which one is better for beginners?

The more forgiving, control-oriented paddle. You’ll learn the soft game faster, and that’s where most points are won.

Which one should you choose?

  • Choose the SLK Evo if you already play every week or plan to join a league or clinic.
  • Choose the Franklin if you’re buying a few paddles for the family or aren’t sure the sport will stick.

Want something even better? See my full list of the best pickleball paddles.

N

Written by Nesli

I’m a racket-sport-obsessed player and coach. I write the guides I wish I had when I started: clear, honest and easy to act on. How I pick products →

Keep reading